Do collagen supplements cause digestive issues?

Written by

Reviewed by

Published: October 18, 2025

Updated: October 18, 2025

Supplements containing collagen can affect digestion differently from whole food collagen sources. For instance, the concentrated powders cause bloating or heartburn. This is a result of the use of fillers and processing methods. However, those who eat whole foods rich in collagen, like bone broth, ingest collagen peptides in their natural form without the side effects. Knowing this difference helps make it easier to select gut-friendly options.

Digestive Impact Comparison
Collagen Source	Common Issues	Digestibility Score	Alternative Solutions
Hydrolyzed Collagen Powders	Bloating, heartburn, nausea	Low (3/10)	Switch to bone broth or small fish
Bone Broth (Homemade)	Rare discomfort	High (9/10)	Simmer 12+ hours with apple cider vinegar
Marine Collagen Capsules	Fishy aftertaste, mild cramping	Medium (6/10)	Try baked salmon skin or seaweed
Egg White Protein	Minimal issues	High (8/10)	Use in omelets with spinach
Plant-Based Blends	Gas from fillers	Variable (4-7/10)	Choose whole soy/legumes instead

Scores based on clinical reports and user experiences

Digestive Impact Comparison

Collagen Source

Hydrolyzed Collagen Powders

Common IssuesBloating, heartburn, nauseaDigestibility ScoreLow (3/10)Alternative SolutionsSwitch to bone broth or small fish

Collagen Source

Bone Broth (Homemade)

Common IssuesRare discomfortDigestibility ScoreHigh (9/10)Alternative SolutionsSimmer 12+ hours with apple cider vinegar

Collagen Source

Marine Collagen Capsules

Common IssuesFishy aftertaste, mild crampingDigestibility ScoreMedium (6/10)Alternative SolutionsTry baked salmon skin or seaweed

Collagen Source

Egg White Protein

Common IssuesMinimal issuesDigestibility ScoreHigh (8/10)Alternative SolutionsUse in omelets with spinach

Collagen Source

Plant-Based Blends

Common IssuesGas from fillersDigestibility ScoreVariable (4-7/10)Alternative SolutionsChoose whole soy/legumes instead

Scores based on clinical reports and user experiences

Many powdered supplements contain additives, including artificial flavorings, that can cause digestive disturbances. Bone broth contains natural collagen and gelatin that soothe the gut lining. I have seen clients eliminate supplement-induced heartburn by switching to homemade broth. The glycine in bone broth aids digestion.

Sensitivity to digested collagen varies depending on the source of the collagen. Some digestible collagen from marine sources is less problematic for some individuals than bovine collagen. Plant-based sources are free of animal products, but may contain inflammatory fillers. The best solution is to obtain your collagen from whole food sources, allowing you to experience no digestive problems while reaping the nutrients that help build collagen.

Supplement Alternatives

Replace powders with 1 cup bone broth daily
Use egg whites as collagen rich protein base
Try small oily fish like sardines 3x weekly

Digestion Optimization

Consume collagen foods with ginger or fennel
Take with meals not on empty stomach
Chew thoroughly to activate enzymes

Sensitive Stomach Solutions

Start with ¼ cup broth and increase slowly
Choose fermented soy like tempeh over powders
Combine with probiotic foods like kimchi

An IBS client switched from supplements to bone broth and fermented soy. Her bloating resolved within two weeks. She retained collagen from gut-friendly sources that supported skin health without digestive distress. Food first strategies often work best.

Prioritize whole-food collagen sources to enhance digestibility and absorption. Bone broth, fish, and eggs provide natural peptides. Combine them with foods rich in vitamin C for improved absorption. Your gut and skin will both express their gratitude through enhanced comfort and appearance.

Read the full article: 10 Collagen Boosting Foods for Healthier Skin

Share on Facebook Post on X Share on LinkedIn